Train up a child in the way he should go,
And when he is old he will not depart from it.
Proverbs 22:6
This isn’t the first time I’ve posted about Jewel’s adventures with “Church Babies”. It seems to have more issues come up than we ever experience with the main church services, or Nick with the youth programs… Why is that?
We’ve visited a local church for several Sundays now, and the service and youth programs seem pretty satisfying. You can hear the “but” coming, right?
As always, the first time in a new place, I stayed through the service in the nursery with Jewel. I try to sit out of the way, and encourage her to engage rather than be with me, but I’m there if she needs me - which she does.
I was a little alarmed by the behavior that was going on in the room. Kids were running around crazily, kids were throwing building blocks across the room, kids were destroying the doll stroller by riding in it themselves… And when something got really out of control, the adult (or their teen “helper”) in charge would tell them to stop. But it was pretty wild, and very noisy.
Jewel, my little easy-going child, is NOT wild, and NOT noisy — and was quite disturbed by it. She hung out at the table with me and did puzzles. She had a nice time, but it lacked the “playing with other kids your own age” benefit that is one of the main reasons we take her to nursery rather than just having her in the service with us.
The second week rolled around, and a different adult and teen were supervising. But the result was much the same. This time I discussed things with her a little more - carefully! - trying to feel the situation out. She blamed it primarly on this specific week having been someone’s birthday, so the kids were loaded up with sugar from the snacks the mom brought. (I didn’t see much difference from the previous week!).
Week three, and it was reluctantly that I even took Jewel to nursery. The mom of one of the biggest troublemakers was the adult in charge, so I had high hopes. Alas! After the second child was injured (luckily nothing really serious, but…), I took Jewel out and we joined Wolf and Nick in the main service.
Church members and staff (including the nursery director) that we discussed the situation with had answers that were equally troubling:
- “Our kids all grew up together, so this is like their second home.” Wow - you mean you let them act like that at home?
- “They just sat through Sunday School for an hour, so this is free play time, and they need to burn off their energy.” In a steel-cage death match?
- “You know, some of the neighborhood kids come, so they’re not being raised in a Christian environment…” True, doubtless - but the two worst offenders are the children of church staff.
- “We have a lot of toruble getting volunteers. We don’t want to ask to much of them, or we won’t have any!” I don’t even know how to respond to that. We will tolerate disrespect and disobedience in our children, for the sake of convenience?
The nursery director, in addition to some of the above, said that I was welcome to keep her in service with me, of course, or that we could take her to the younger room, for infants and 1 year-olds. As poorly as she fits in with the 2-3 crowd, I don’t think that would be a good answer, either.
Wolf and I have reached a few conclusions, a few theories, and a few more questions…
I think there is some amount of cultural/regional influence at play in the way children are expected to behave. In Mississippi and elsewhere in the Deep South, children typically say “Yes, Sir” and “Yes, Ma’am.” Here, although further South, we are actually in a more “California” environment, and child-centered households are quite normal, even in the Church.
We like the 2 and 3 Year Old Sunday School teacher, and the hour she has them they seem perfectly able to behave. This leads us to think that (a) the children have not yet completely devolved into a Lord of the Flies scenario as you might guess from viewing them during nursery, and (b) maybe we should take her to Sunday School, then pull her out when they switch over to nursery.
Personally, I think this typifies the way I see the Church as a whole drifting. By now we’ve probably all heard the statistic that divorce is just as common in the Church as in the U.S. as a whole. Last summer there were two pregnancies among “good” teens at our then-church. Just look around next Sunday at what people are wearing - do we show respect to the Lord when we enter his house in ratty jeans, mini-skirts, flip-flops, or with brazen cleavage? A lot of compromise is accepted, and people just seem to shrug it off and say, “that’s just how the world today is.” Have we forgotten that we are not to be conformed to the world, but transformed by the renewing of our minds (Romans 12:2)? I guess that’s a whole ‘nother soapbox…
So what’s a concerned mama to do?
I’d love to volunteer in the nursery, but with the little one on the way and not knowing how our situation here will be when Wolf starts working, I’m not ready to make that commitment. And even if I did, the situation would still be an issue the other 80% of the time (or however many volunteers they have).
Do we just take her into service and look for social time elsewhere? Leave her with the babies - and look for social time elsewhere? Find a new church?